- Bad Astronomy Newsletter
- Posts
- JWST finds its first old, cold giant exoplanet!
JWST finds its first old, cold giant exoplanet!
The nearby Jupiter-like world orbits Epsilon Indi A, a star less than 12 light-years from us
July 25, 2024 Issue #752
Astronomy News
It’s a big Universe. Here’s a thing about it.
Well, this is a big deal: Astronomers have discovered a very nearby gas giant exoplanet through direct imaging with JWST! A few exoplanets have been seen by JWST before, but this is the first one discovered in JWST data. On top of that, it’s the second closest Jovian (Jupiter-like) exoplanet known!
Epsilon Indi is visible to the naked eye as a faint orange star in the southern constellation of Indus. It’s actually a triple system: The primary (called Epsilon Indi A, or Eps Ind A for short) is a K-type star, meaning it’s slightly less massive, cooler, and smaller than the Sun. It’s orbited by a binary pair of brown dwarfs. Such a system consisting of a single star orbited by a binary pair is called a hierarchical triple, just so’s you know. The brown dwarfs are very far from the primary, about a fifth of a light-year, and take millennia to orbit. The system as a whole is about 11.9 light-years from Earth, making it one of the closest to us (the 20th closest known in fact).
Over the years, careful observations of Eps Ind A showed some peculiarities. Its motion through space has a slight wobble to it, hinting at a big planet orbiting it, tugging it gravitationally as it moves. There’s also a slight Doppler shift in its spectrum (called the radial or reflex velocity) that indicated a planet as well. The data aren’t clear, but the best guess was that the planet was about three times the mass of Jupiter on an orbit roughly 1.6 billion kilometers out from the star, a bit farther out than Saturn is from the Sun.
A planet like that should be relatively cool in temperature, which means it emits infrared light. JWST is designed to look at those wavelengths, so astronomers pointed the observatory at Eps Ind A to see what they could see [link to journal paper].
And what they got was a surprise. They put the primary star behind an occulting mask, a piece of metal that blocks the glare from bright objects so that fainter nearby objects can be seen. And sure enough, right next to the star is a fainter point of light. Could it be the planet?
![Side by side images of the exoplanet seen at two different wavelengths show it as a small blob near the position of the star.](https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,format=auto,onerror=redirect,quality=80/uploads/asset/file/6da35f13-8fe6-4fb5-80c4-eedf03da8d99/eps_indi_Ab_jwst.jpg?t=1721844233)
Two images of Epsilon Indi Ab from JWST, one at a wavelength of 10.65 microns (left) and the other at 15.5 microns. In both, the star itself has been blocked with a star icon marking its position. The background image is from the WISE infrared observatory. Credit: T. Müller (MPIA/HdA), E. Matthews (MPIA)
They were able to statistically rule out the object being a distant background galaxy — such a galaxy would be extended in the image, and the object is clearly unresolved, a dot. Also, the Eps Ind system moves pretty rapidly through space, and over the years would have moved significantly relative to any background source. Older infrared data shows no such object at the position seen, when it should be pretty obvious. That means the object is moving along with Eps Ind A.
Also, the brightness and color (the difference in brightness between two images taken in different filters) are consistent with it being a gas giant exoplanet. The formal designation for it is Epsilon Indi Ab.
But this is where things get weird. For one, it’s not at all in the position predicted using the previous data. It’s also far too bright to be a planet with three times Jupiter’s mass. What went wrong? The astronomers aren’t sure, but it’s likely the predictions made were inaccurate due to the uncertainties in the original pre-JWST data. It’s possible to get multiple solutions for a planet’s characteristics when the data aren’t great, so the old estimates probably just converged on the wrong solution.
Combining the old observations with the new ones from JWST, the astronomers find that Epsilon Indi Ab has a mass of a little over 6 times that of Jupiter on an elliptical orbit well over 4 billion kilometers out from the star. That’s much more massive and farther out than the previous estimates!
![](https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/format=auto,onerror=redirect/uploads/publication/logo/13461c87-ca80-4ea7-ab99-53333e594ec8/thumb_BAN_logo_adamblock_m81_800x800.jpg)
Subscribe to Premium Membership to read the rest.
Become a paying subscriber of Premium Membership to get access to this post and other subscriber-only content.
Already a paying subscriber? Sign In
Reply